Who wins?
West Side Story vs Moulin Rouge!
West Side Story wins 57% to 43%. 62 more put them in the same row. From Movie Musicals Tier List. Pick a side.
MrBiscuit2k on West Side Story: both versions are great, Spielberg's remake made it S for me
throwaway66832 on Moulin Rouge!: ten times better than the stage musical, the Elephant Love Medley
Movie Musicals Tier List: the full ranking