Who wins?
CatDog vs iCarly
iCarly wins 75% to 25%. 10 more put them in the same row. From Nickelodeon Shows (90s & 2000s) Tier List. Pick a side.
joshs78 on CatDog: Winslow and the Greaser Dogs were funny even if the main idea is gross
goblingamer3780 on iCarly: Spencer carried every episode
Nickelodeon Shows (90s & 2000s) Tier List: the full ranking