Who wins?
All That vs iCarly
All That wins 54% to 46%. 22 more put them in the same row. From Nickelodeon Shows (90s & 2000s) Tier List. Pick a side.
sam_a1310 on All That: Good Burger started here and that's enough
goblingamer3780 on iCarly: Spencer carried every episode
Nickelodeon Shows (90s & 2000s) Tier List: the full ranking