Who wins?
Diplomacy vs Catan
Diplomacy wins 81% to 19%. 66 more put them in the same row. From Board Games That Ruin Friendships Tier List. Pick a side.
kim_k20 on Diplomacy: betrayal is literally the mechanic, you're supposed to lie to your allies
angry_goblin on Catan: putting the robber on someone's 8 tile starts a cold war that lasts until Christmas
Board Games That Ruin Friendships Tier List: the full ranking