Who wins?
Carousel vs Pirate ship
Pirate ship wins 90% to 10%. 3 more put them in the same row. From Theme Park Ride Types Tier List. Pick a side.
TylerRates on Carousel: fine for little kids, I'll ride it with my niece
WeirdRaccoon on Pirate ship: sit in the very last row, it's a genuinely scary ride
Theme Park Ride Types Tier List: the full ranking