Food & Drink

Girl Scout Cookies Tier List

The once-a-year cookie draft, from freezer royalty to the box nobody opens.

Ranked by 18 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

A: Thin Mints, Samoas / Caramel deLites, Savannah Smiles, Tagalongs

B: Lemonades, Raspberry Rally, Do-si-dos, Trefoils

C: Girl Scout S'mores, Adventurefuls

D: Lemon-Ups, Toffee-tastic

Discussion

DrunkOtter63: rip Savannah Smiles, the powdered sugar lemon ones were perfect

silent_moose_53: Samoas tied at the top is right but it depends on your bakery. Caramel deLites from ABC are a different cookie and everyone in a Little Brownie area knows it.

DarkMango8: coconut ruins everything it touches, Samoas in S is wild

ItsGecko69: Thin Mints are only S if they've lived in the freezer. Room temp they're a solid B.

dave_r63: Lemon-Ups have 'I AM A LEADER' stamped on them. I just wanted a cookie, not a performance review

More Food & Drink tier lists

• Fruits by How Annoying They Are to Eat Tier List
• Pie Flavors Tier List
• Boba/Bubble Tea Chains Tier List
• Pasta Shapes Tier List
• Energy Drinks Tier List
• Pizza Chains Tier List
• Coffee Drinks Tier List
• World Cuisines Tier List