Food & Drink
Girl Scout Cookies Tier List
Thin Mints straight from the freezer are elite. Samoas are still better and that's my hill
Ranked by 47 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.
The crowd's ranking
S: Thin Mints
A: Samoas / Caramel deLites, Savannah Smiles, Tagalongs
B: Do-si-dos, Raspberry Rally, Lemonades
C: Girl Scout S'mores, Adventurefuls, Trefoils
D: Lemon-Ups, Toffee-tastic
Discussion
emilyj8166: Thin Mints are only S if they've lived in the freezer. Room temp they're a solid B.
quiet_panda_29: Samoas tied at the top is right but it depends on your bakery. Caramel deLites from ABC are a different cookie and everyone in a Little Brownie area knows it.
cactusstan: Lemon-Ups have 'I AM A LEADER' stamped on them. I just wanted a cookie, not a performance review
picklegamer: coconut ruins everything it touches, Samoas in S is wild
throwaway85251: rip Savannah Smiles, the powdered sugar lemon ones were perfect