Sports
Greatest Baseball Players Tier List
Babe Ruth was an elite pitcher AND the best hitter alive. nobody else did both until Ohtani
Ranked by 42 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.
The crowd's ranking
S: Willie Mays, Babe Ruth
A: Ted Williams
B: Hank Aaron, Barry Bonds, Stan Musial, Mickey Mantle
C: Ty Cobb, Joe DiMaggio
Discussion
GrumpyRaccoon45: Ruth is the answer. He was out-homering entire teams and also happened to be a great pitcher first.
NotPigeon69: no, it's Connor Norby
andre.m66: DiMaggio isn't in the GOAT conversation. The hit streak is cool but the offensive gap to Ruth is huge.
picklegamer: Ted Williams by the numbers is close. 187 wRC+ vs Ruth's 193 and he lost three prime years to the war.
More Sports tier lists
- Cristiano Ronaldo's Greatest Moments Tier List
- MLB 2026 Postseason Teams Tier List
- Football (Soccer) GOATs Tier List
- Roger Federer's Greatest Moments Tier List
- Muhammad Ali's Greatest Moments Tier List
- Kobe Bryant's Greatest Moments Tier List
- Most Hated NFL Teams Tier List
- Neymar's Greatest Moments Tier List