Who wins?
Cartman vs Butters
Cartman wins 51% to 49%. 83 more put them in the same row. From South Park Characters Tier List. Pick a side.
RetiredGoose63 on Cartman: Scott Tenorman Must Die is the darkest and funniest thing on TV
throwaway10894 on Butters: Professor Chaos is the least threatening supervillain ever and I love him
South Park Characters Tier List: the full ranking