Who wins?
Pibb Xtra vs Gatorade
Gatorade wins 61% to 39%. 15 more put them in the same row. From Soft Drinks & Sodas Tier List. Pick a side.
RealPenguin2k on Pibb Xtra: best Dr Pepper knockoff
luisr3866 on Gatorade: glacier freeze after a hot run
Soft Drinks & Sodas Tier List: the full ranking