Music

Mariah Carey Albums Tier List

Ranking Mariah Carey's R&B and pop albums.

Ranked by 49 people. Sign in to add your own ranking.

The crowd's ranking

S: Daydream, Butterfly

A: Emancipation of Mimi, Music Box

B: Mariah Carey, Emotions

C: Caution, Vision of Love

D: Hero

Discussion

picklemain: Butterfly was the soundtrack to my senior year. Always S.

zach.s1774: Butterfly is the moment she stopped being the label's ballad machine and started making the music she wanted

throwaway94884: Hero and Vision of Love are songs, not albums

BoredWalrus13: Mimi only A? We Belong Together was the song of 2005.

More Music tier lists

• Pop Divas Tier List
• TV Theme Songs Tier List
• Grammys 2026 Album of the Year Nominees Tier List
• The Beatles Albums Tier List
• KPop Demon Hunters Soundtrack Songs Tier List
• Country Artists Tier List
• Pink Floyd Albums Tier List
• Lana Del Rey Albums Tier List