Who wins?
Portgas D. Ace vs Shanks
Portgas D. Ace wins 82% to 18%. 78 more put them in the same row. From One Piece Characters Tier List. Pick a side.
random_falcon on Portgas D. Ace: "thank you for loving me" still gets me
salty_panda on Shanks: presence alone ended a war, every appearance is a hype moment
One Piece Characters Tier List: the full ranking