Who wins?

Game 7 win over Boston (2010) vs First ring without Shaq (2009)

First ring without Shaq (2009) wins 58% to 42%. 82 more put them in the same row. From Kobe Bryant's Greatest Moments Tier List. Pick a side.

soggy_dumpling_71 on Game 7 win over Boston (2010): Beating the Celtics for ring five meant more than any other title he won

HumbleRaccoon on First ring without Shaq (2009): That smirk after the clinch said everything about how bad he wanted that one

Kobe Bryant's Greatest Moments Tier List: the full ranking

More matchups

• Game 7 win over Boston (2010) vs 62 in three quarters vs Dallas (2005)
• Game 7 win over Boston (2010) vs Silencer four-point play vs Spain (2008)
• Game 7 win over Boston (2010) vs Taking over Game 4 after Shaq fouled out (2000)
• First ring without Shaq (2009) vs Free throws on a torn Achilles (2013)
• First ring without Shaq (2009) vs 62 in three quarters vs Dallas (2005)
• First ring without Shaq (2009) vs 60 in the final game (2016)